The restructuring and privatisation trajectory in south. Neoliberalism and privatisation in south africa sagie narsiah department of geography, university of natal, pietermaritzburg, republic of south africa email. Pdf the state, privatisation and the public sector in south africa. Privatization in south africa under the nationalist party. It investigates the experiences of these countries and derives lessons that can be learnt. Although reduction of fiscal deficits is commonly cited as the main objective for the adoption of privatization in africa, the choices of enterprises for privatization suggests that the primary motivations for privatization have been the need for the. This report discussed the evolution and prospects of. This research investigation focused on the privatisation of prisons and prison services in south africa and has explored the various advantages and disadvantages that exist in this respect. The impact of decentralization and privatization on municipal. In south africa, there has been a movement from a development policy with a socialist resonance the reconstruction and development program rdp to one decidedly neoliberal in form and substance the growth employment and redistribution gear policy. In this chapter, the researcher defines the research problem and objectives. This report on privatization and its impact on the right to education of women and girls, is informed by an econsultation held via the right to education project discussion forum, as well as over facebook and twitter. South africa stwo prisons were the countrysfirst ppp projects.
South africa s mining industry is supported by an extensive and diversified to the governments philosophy and policy on competition and privatisation. Jurisdiction like south africa, it is believed that commercialisation is one of the phases of privatisation. South africa economy chief hints at privatization, moodys. Although the national party government of south africa expressed its allegiance to an economic system of markets, the government sector in south africa produced the highest proportion of gdp of any country outside of the marxist socialist bloc. Up to that time, privatization throughout the continent had been slow, with few visible results and a general feeling among observers and donors that african governments commitment to the process was generally halfhearted. Privatization has been an important issue for the republic of south africa for over two decades. Privatisation in south africa and africa free market foundation. Nationalisation in the reasons to nationalise south. It is the project teams hope that this study brings to the fore a political and strategic. Air transport bureau, economic analysis and policy eap section in august 1996, the government issued a white paper on national transport policy stating that strategies to attract foreign capital, technology and.
Privatization, a method of reallocating assets and functions from the public sector to the private sector, appears to be a factor that could play a serious role in the quest for growth. The circular flow of inefficiency of stateowned enterprises soes. The process in which a publiclytraded company is taken over by a few people is also called privatization. Advantages and disadvantages of privatization the merits and drawbacks of privatization have been subjects of considerable debate among businesspeople, city leaders, and public employees alike. Privatization of specific government operations happens in a number of ways, though generally, the government transfers ownership of specific. In recent years several showcase water privatizations have suffered major losses.
The resulting desk research on south africa s experience of privatisation is the basis for this book. Also the treatise looks at alternative solutions to conquer this crisis, with its main objective to investigate whether privitisation or part privitisation of the electricity industry could be a solution available to south africa. The alternative to privatisation is continued poor governance, crony capitalism, neverending rising costs in both tax payers and consumers, and a continued delay in meeting the countrys need to upgrade and expand its economic infrastructure, according. Many countries, also in africa, implemented various types of privatisation programmes over the past two. The argument that saa is a strategic asset, required in case all other airlines withdraw from south africa, is quite illogical. Comair privatisation of saa, the most logical solution. Financial performance of uganda post and telecommunications corporation. The role and significance of state owned enterprises, public. Strategic implications for the platinum group metals. The first is the shift in government policy in favour of greater private sector participation in hearth care. Some companies are not directly controlled by the department of public enterprises, but by various other departments. Neoliberalism and privatisation in south africa springerlink. Privatization and its impact on the right to education of.
The first group to start such programs in the late 1970s to early 1980s was composed of francophone west african countries e. Pdf the state, privatisation and the public sector in south. The thinking of privatisation and restructu ring in south africa can be traced directly from the white paper on privatisation and deregulation in the state consumption expenditure must be curtailed as far as possible. Get an answer for what are the advantages and disadvantages of the privatisation of governmentowned companies such as airlines. Indeed, each element of privatization from its apparent costsaving properties to its possible negative impact on.
Privatisation and the broadening of ownership of state. In july 1993, the airports company south africa limited acsa was established under the airports company act act no. The overall rationale is that privatisation operations entail a reshuffling of assets in the balance sheet of the government. In order to answer the main problem, four subproblems need to be investigated. In south africa, this janusfaced character is revealed by the juxtaposition of economic and political arguments for and against the process of privatisation initiated by the national party. The revenues from privatization have been more limited in africa, the. The world bank has encouraged a policy of water privatization ever since the neoliberal policies of reagan and thatcher came into favor in the 1970s. Mar 26, 2018 south africa s economy grew by an unexpected 3. In 1955, the main liberation movement in south africa, the. Mcdonald, david a, and john pape, cost recovery and the crisis of service delivery in south africa, zed press, london, 2002. This paper analyses the two major factors that have affected the trend towards privatization in the health sector in south africa. South africas mining industry is supported by an extensive and diversified to the governments philosophy and policy on competition and privatisation. Is privatisation of the electricity industry in south africa a solution to the electricity crisis of the country. The struggle against water privatisation in south africa.
Stateowned enterprises play a significant role in the south african economy. Assessing the impact of privatization in africa funded by the norwegian trust fund and cofunded by publicprivate infrastructure advisory facility managed by the investment climate department and africa private sector and. The contracting process, which took place throughout the mid to late 1990s, was conducted under a great deal ofsecrecy and, to this day, public awareness ofthese prisons is. South africa and the privatization, or partial privatization, ofa number ofsouth african public services.
The new debate around commodity cycles is, will south africa. Telkom gradually privatised starting with the ipo in 2003. The timing and context of south africas privatisation process is difficult to defend on economic grounds, but it did make political. The resulting desk research on south africas experience of privatisation is the basis for this book. Privatisation started in south africa before it had started elsewhere in africa. Jun 20, 2011 privatization of water is also one of the main demands the g8 leaders are imposing on countries seeking debt relief and further aid. Proponents of privatization believe that private market actors can more efficiently deliver many goods or service than government due to free market competition. This is the founding declaration of the coalition against water privatisation cawp. If privatisation is properly executed, then it can be beneficial for south africa. The government ceases to be the owner of the entity or business. Arguably, privatization in south africa had been slow, with few visible results. Indymedia south africa in 1996, postapartheid south africa adopted its remarkably progressive constitution, which granted all citizens the basic right to. The second is the increase in medical aid scheme membership.
Chapters 3 and 4 describe current trends in decentralization and privatization in the various sectors of municipal services. When examining the list of national entities in south africa, it is evident that many have a direct impact on urban growth and development. Privatization programs in subsaharan africa ssa occurred in successive waves, with some countries privatizing much earlier than others bennell 1997. Nationalisation in the reasons to nationalise south africa. Declaration of the coalition against water privatisation. Given the above context, this study will adopt a twopronged approach to examine some of the challenges facing soes in south africa. Cases in buenos aires, manila, atlantaand cochabamba are presented below. Pdf this study evaluates south african privatisation or restructuring.
Conflictridden water privatizations in indonesia, south africa, and the united kingdomare also analyzed. By 1986 a noticeable decline in copper production resulted in the closure of many mining units and led to the implementation of a fiveyear plan to revive the company8. South africa responded as best as it could and in the end some commodities grew their global market share, but some others lost market share. Since 1992, six privatization contracts were awarded to foreign, mainly french, companies in south africa. Oecd 2018, privatisation and the broadening of ownership of stateowned enterprises this work is published on the responsibility of the secretarygeneral of the oecd. Privatisation is so ideologically loaded a word in south africa that mere mention is enough to provoke protest, so we use euphemisms like restructuring. Iscor now known as arcelormittal south africa, the company was privatised in 1989. African national congress anc, adopted the freedom. There would be a lot more activity from both private domestic and international. Privatisation is inevitable in sa but you may not r. Uganda water one of eight papers from a project entitled. South africa had more than enough electricity to sustain its economy and provide electricity to the public.
A solution to problems of public enterprises 37 fig. History examples, and issues page executive summary i i. From nationalisation to privatisation in south africa nationalisation of the mines, banks and monopoly industries is the policy of the anc and a change or modification of our views in this regard is inconceivable. The ownership and responsibility for the operation of the nine governmentowned airports with all assets and liabilities were vested in. Allafrica is a voice of, by and about africa aggregating, producing and distributing 900 news and information items daily from over 140 african news organizations and our own reporters to an. An anti privatization activist argues with police guarding the installation of prepaid water meters in soweto. In recent history, privatization has been adopted by many different political systems and has spread to every region of the world. Finance minister tito mboweni delivers his maiden budget speech in parliament, cape town, 20 february 2019. Also, in south africa the post apartheid government inherited more than 300 stateowned enterprises and in 1995, president thabo mbeki then deputy president, announced plans for widesweeping privatisation programmes of which some eventually. Privatization in africa is the outcome of a study undertaken during 1995 and 1996. Indymedia south africa in 1996, postapartheid south africa adopted its remarkably progressive constitution, which granted all citizens the basic right to housing, water, health care, and other essentials. The role and significance of state owned enterprises. Objectives of privatization the main objectives of privatization may be summarized in the following. The biggest advantage of privatization is that once a privatization is done completely there is no interference from political leaders and also one does not need to do undue favor to them which in itself is a big boost when it comes to doing business and increasing profitability.
The painful privatisation of south africa international. Pdf on jun 1, 2006, stephen greenberg and others published the state, privatisation and the public sector in south africa find, read and. Partial privatization of utl with 51% of the shares sold february, 2000. Water privatisation and socioeconomic rights in south africa. In south africa the department of public enterprises is the shareholder representative of the south african government with oversight responsibility for stateowned enterprises in key sectors. Nov 03, 2010 the world bank has encouraged a policy of water privatization ever since the neoliberal policies of reagan and thatcher came into favor in the 1970s.
Water privatisation and socioeconomic rights in south africa danwood mzikenge chirwa lecturer, university of cape town 1 introduction several studies of privatisation. Explaining trends in the privatization of health services in. The privitisation of the electricity industry in south africa. In south africa, there has been a movement from a development policy with a socialist resonance the reconstruction and development program rdp to one decidedly neoliberal in form and. Another 33 % came from sales in a group of four actively privatizing countries ghana, nigeria, zambia. Yet however varied and at times unclear in its meaning, privatization has unambiguous political origins and objectives. Under the former apartheid regime the privatisation programme included the iron and steel, and the petroleum industries. In general, over time this will lead to lower prices, improved quality, more choices, less corruption, less red tape, and quicker delivery. Pdf the tortuous road to privatisation and restructuring of state. Up to that time, privatization throughout the continent had been slow, with few visible results and a general feeling among observers and donors that african governments. It covers a great range of ideas and policies, varying from the eminently reasonable to the wildly impractical. Pdf on jun 1, 2006, stephen greenberg and others published the state, privatisation and the public sector in south africa find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Water privatisation and socioeconomic rights in south africa danwood mzikenge chirwa lecturer, university of cape town 1 introduction several studies of privatisation have been conducted but have rarely done. The transfer of ownership, property or business from the government to the private sector is termed privatization. The sale of south africa s state companies appears to be speeding up, but the process will be anything but straightforward. The potential of manufacturing and industrialization in africa. Finally it assesses the possible impact of the privatisation of essential service delivery on poor households in rwanda. This paper examines the promise and challenge of infrastructure privatization in subsaharan africa, with particular emphasis on power, telecommunications, water, rail, ports and airports. The sale of south africas state companies appears to be speeding up, but the process will be anything but straightforward. Pdf neoliberalism and privatisation in south africa. As one of the key campaign pillars of the anti privatisation forum apf since its formation, the struggle against the privatisation of water was taken up in communities early in the apf s history. The experience ofservice privatization in developing. What has now become clear is that the major multinational. Oct 03, 2019 privatization of specific government operations happens in a number of ways, though generally, the government transfers ownership of specific facilities or business processes to a private, for. In south africa, privatized water can cost up to 20 per cent of income. Copessa, ngos, parks, public places, privatisation, and south africa.
The state, privatisation and the public sector in south africa. Privatization and restructuring of state assets in south africa. Privatization is a fuzzy concept that evokes sharp political reactions. Sep 21, 2016 if privatisation is properly executed, then it can be beneficial for south africa. The discussion forum is a global, multilingual online forum. The bank acknowledged that the poor would stop paying for water once the cost was more than five percent of income.
72 1146 568 988 481 702 1173 231 112 1468 360 1484 1512 429 1552 1149 1561 639 1629 477 883 1011 660 653 798 1371 674 344 698 1597 430 983 1202 1055 582 1005 1487 131 1374 1172 1081 775 1416 1473